Showing posts with label crisis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label crisis. Show all posts

Friday, June 24, 2016

Brexit - ein schrecklich historischer Tag

Für einen bekennenden Europäer wie mich aber auch ein schrecklicher Tag. Auch wenn das offizielle Endergebnis noch nicht da ist, scheint das Brexit-Lager uneinholbar vorne zu liegen. Zusammen mit den Kollegen aus London werden wir am frühen Vormittag eine längere Research Note veröffentlichen. Bevor diese kommt, hier schon eine kurze Stellungnahme. Es sieht so aus, als ob Europas schlimmster Alptraum Wahrheit geworden ist. Sollte sich das Ergebnis bewahrheiten, werden die wirtschaftlichen und politischen Folgen noch lange zu fühlen sein. Die erste Marktreaktion gibt schon einen guten Vorgeschmack. Es steht ein langer, schwieriger und dreckiger Scheidungsprozess an. Es wird nicht nur schwierige Verhandlungen mit Großbritannien geben. Europa wird sich auch mit sich selbst beschäftigen müssen. Nach dem heutigen Tag wird Europa nie mehr so sein wie bisher. Der Geist des Populismus und antieuropäischer Haltungen ist aus der Flasche entwichen und wird nur sehr schwer einzufangen sein. Europa befindet sich in einer existentiellen, in einer Identitätskrise. Nach dem Brexit ist vor der nächsten Exit-Gefahr. Schon jetzt gibt es Spekulationen über mögliche EU-Abstimmungen in Frankreich und den Niederlanden; zwei Gründungsmitglieder der EU. Die Wahrscheinlichkeit einer schleichenden Desintegration der EU und auch der Eurozone nimmt zu. Die Gefahr, dass die nächste Generation, unsere Kinder, diese Scherben aufräumen muss, auch. Europa muss die Kritik und Skepsis in Teilen der Bevölkerung ernst nehmen. Die aktuelle Europa-Diskussion dreht sich fast immer nur um ‚mehr oder weniger’ Europa. Europa braucht eine neue differenzierte Diskussion über die Zukunft Europas. Eine Diskussion, in der positive Alternativen aufgezeigt und die Ängste ernst genommen werden. Eine Diskussion, die nicht sich nicht mehr um ‚mehr oder weniger’ drehen sollte, sondern um ‚mehr und weniger’. So könnte ein historisch schrecklicher Tag irgendwann vielleicht doch einmal als Anfang eines besseren Europas in den Geschichtsbüchern stehen. Das ist aber vielleicht nur der Traum eines verträumten Europäers.

Monday, October 27, 2014

Downward slide continues

Downward slide continues. German business confidence dropped for the sixth month in a row in October, illustrating the Eurozone’s biggest economy has reached a dangerous stage between soft spell and longer-lasting almost-stagnation. Germany's most prominent leading indicator, the Ifo index, just decreased to 103.2, from 104.7 in September. Both the current assessment and the expectation component slowed down. Particularly the weaker expectation component, which dropped to its lowest level since December 2012, is a reason for further caution. Latest soft data has rather increased than decreased the degree of diffusion, maybe even confusion. While last week’s PMI and consumer confidence indicator had given hope that the economy would slowly recover from the psychological shock waves from the summer, today’s Ifo index is less encouraging. Trying to get some grip on the current state of the economy requires a lot of instinctive feel. At the current juncture, it is still hard to tell whether solid domestic demand can offset weaker industrial activity; and if for how long. While the strong labour market and low interest rates are supporting private consumption and the construction sector, the export-oriented industry is still going through a dry spell. However, the latest reductions in backlogs and optimism stemming from new Chinese bulk orders show that the risk of drying-up is still relatively small. Looking ahead, Germany’s export industry will face several opposing trends in the next months: on the negative side, with France and Italy stagnating, demand from the Eurozone should remain weak. On the positive side, however, the strong US recovery and renewed demand from China bode well for exports. In our view, the German economy is neither near the abyss, nor close to a period of self-complacent honky-dory. It is in a longer-lasting transition period from the end of the positive reform cycle to the challenges an ageing economy is facing. Even if it is does not make sense to use single economic data as a barometer on whether or not the government will decide on growth-enhancing measures, the general need for more domestic investment in Germany remains. Last week’s European Summit, which took place off markets’ radar screens due to the stress test excitement, did not provide any further guidance. While statements in the final summit conclusions like “…the urgency of the prompt implementation of measures to boost jobs, growth, competitiveness…” sounded promising to those hoping for additional fiscal stimulus, the Germanic sentence “structural reforms and sound public finances are key conditions for investment” underlined that the face-off between Germany and the rest of Europe on how to revive the Eurozone economy is far from being solved. In the short run, lower energy prices and the weaker euro exchange rate are already a small stimulus package for the German economy. However, it is a package which will rather delay than advance new structural reforms.

Wednesday, August 7, 2013

Industrial production points to strong growth comeback of German economy

Impressive comeback. The German economy is on a good way towards an impressive growth comeback in the second quarter. Industrial production increased by 2.4% MoM in June, after an 0.8% MoM drop in May. The increase in production was broadly-based across all sectors. Production in the construction sector increased by 1.6% MoM. Compared with 1Q 13, industrial production was up by 3.4% in 2Q.
 
Slowly but surely industrial activity has returned as an important growth driver for the German economy. Since the turn of the year, inventories have remained rather stable, while new orders have gradually picked up. Moreover, the construction sector has staged – the expected – comeback after the harsh winter. Yesterday’s new order data confirmed that the industrial engine will not run out of fuel any time soon. A monthly increase by almost 4% was rather impressive. In fact, improving new orders is not a one-off.  Order books have gradually thickened over the last six months with a quarterly increase of 0.5% QoQ in 1Q 13 and 1.2% QoQ in 2Q.

It looks as if the German economy is again walking on two feet: solid private consumption and strengthening industrial activity. Looking ahead, the biggest short- and medium-term risks for the German economy seem to stem from a further softening of economic activity in emerging economies, above all China, and a longer-lasting economic slump in Germany’s main trading partner: France.

Moreover, another pressing issue for the German economy is weak domestic investment. Yesterday, in its latest Article IV report, the IMF linked weak domestic investment to the euro crisis and falling German exports to Eurozone peers. In our view, there is more to German investment weakness than the euro crisis. In fact, weak domestic investment is not only a recent phenomenon but has been accompanying the German economy for much longer, driven by a preference for foreign rather than domestic investments in the private sector and a significant reduction of public investments. One way or the other, the next German government will have to address the issue of domestic investment to ensure Germany’s leading economic role.

With this week’s data a long rollercoaster ride of the German economy is coming to an end. Since the start of the year, German macro data has been highly erratic. Harsh and persistent winter weather, early Eastern, public holidays and vacation frequently blurred the data and required an extra portion of gut feelings to look through short-term fluctuations. The month of June was the first noise-free month; the month of truth. Data released so far has been very promising, sending two messages: i) the German economy should have staged an impressive growth comeback in the second quarter (with growth somewhere between 0.6% and 0.8% QoQ); and ii) such a comeback could be sufficient to have pushed the entire Eurozone out of the recession.

Friday, May 24, 2013

Ifo points to growth acceleration in Germany

The day ahead of the all-German soccer Champions League final looks like an all-German macro day. Third important data released this morning was the Ifo index. Germany’s most prominent leading indicator, measuring business sentiment, increased sharply to 105.7 in May, from 104.4 in April. While the expectation component remained unchanged, current expectations spurred to 110, from 107.2 in April; the strongest monthly increase since July 2010.

Despite many negative readings from the Eurozone, the last two months have delivered a couple of positive news from the German economy. New orders have increased in February and March, industrial production improved and companies increased their production plans. In fact, since the beginning of the year, we have seen a rather contradictory up-and-down of soft and hard data and it almost required a fog lamp to predict the future path of the German economy. Now, the fog is clearing up. A weather-inflicted catching up of industrial activity, particularly construction, combined continued private consumption could deliver decent growth in the second quarter.

However, the big unknown in the equation remains the export sector. Earlier this week, the Association of German Chambers of Commerce and Industry released the results of a survey showing that German exporters lost some optimism. ONly 30% expect export volumes to increase, while some 10% even expect a decline. The stagnation of the French economy, accounting for around 10% of German total exports, and worrying signals from China could prevent a sharp pick-up in exports. Fortunately, the US economy, the biggest non-euro trading partner, is currently doing better than expected.

All in all, today’s data bode well for the short-term. Growth should accelerate in the second quarter, on the back of domestic demand. However, on the day ahead of the all-German Champions League final, let’s not forget that the German economy without exports is like Barcelona without Messi: a good team but not a champion.

Thursday, May 23, 2013

Spending the recession away

The second estimate of the statistical office confirmed that the German economy avoided a technical recession (of two consecutive negative quarters) only barely. GDP growth in the Eurozone’s biggest economy came in at 0.1% QoQ in the first quarter, from a 0.7% decline in the last quarter of 2012. Growth was driven by private consumption (up by 0.8% QoQ), while investments were down by 2.4% QoQ, mainly driven by a sharp decline in construction. Net exports still contributed 0.1 pp to first quarter growth.

German consumers remain the silent helpers of the economy. Often forgotten, ignored and labelled as had-beens, German consumers have become an important growth driver. In fact, private consumption grew in each since quarter since 1Q 2012.

Looking ahead, all ingredients are in place to see a continuation of solid consumption. The labour market remains stable. Contrary to the rest of the Eurozone, German unemployment has hardly increased (yet) and employment remains close to its record highs. In addition, the increase in real wages, which started last year, should accelerate this year, driven by nominal wage increases of around 3% and low inflation. It therefore does not come as a surprise that this morning’s GfK index posted another increase, pushing German consumer confidence to its highest level since 2007.

Unfortunately, the positive trend of private consumption is anything but a spending spree and Germans are still unlikely to become a bunch of shopaholics. This means that despite all delight, this morning’s data also hold an inconvenient truth which interdicts any euphoria:  without its exports, the German economy is currently only like a sports car without sixth gear.

 

Friday, May 3, 2013

Adjustment continues...but not everywhere

At the end of an exciting week, just two interesting charts, stemming from the European Commission's almost undiscovered data treasure on cost and price competitiveness indicators.

The structural adjustment, Commissioner Olli Rehn mentioned in today's press conference, is indeed continuing. All four Eurozone peripheral countries (IR, GR, PT and SP) have experienced a significant catching up of their cost competitiveness positions vis-a-vis the rest of the Eurozone. However, there are two countries where the adjustment has not even started. Looks as if the Eurozone is heading towards its next big problem...


Wednesday, March 20, 2013

No bailout without bail-in for Cyprus?

Yesterday evening, the Cypriot parliament brought the euro crisis back to the centre stage. The “no” vote on the bailout plan could have marked a new and uncertain stage in the entire euro crisis.


In the end, no single Cypriot parliamentarian was in favour of the bailout package, decided last week by the Eurogroup and the Cypriot government. In last night’s vote, 36 members of parliament voted against the proposal and the other 19 members abstained. The most controversial part of the bailout is the levy on bank deposits. Even a slight revision of the original plan, namely an exemption of deposits below €20,000 did not change parliamentarians’ minds. With the “no” of the Cypriot parliament, there is no bailout for the time being.

So what is next? The ECB already stopped playing hardball and announced last night that it would provide liquidity to Cyprus “within existing rules”. This can buy time but will not solve the Cypriot problems. With the genie of the deposit tax out of the bottle, time is of the essence. Re-opening the banks without a solution would probably lead to a massive capital flight.

In fact, Cyprus has two main ways out of the current deadlock: i) a renegotiation of the current bailout terms with the Eurogroup; or ii) finding other financial sources to fund the required €5.8bn in the bailout.

At the current juncture, a softening of the bailout terms looks unlikely. The Eurogroup will want to keep maximum pressure on Cyprus, stressing that the ball is with Cyprus and that the Eurogroup’s offer for a bailout is still valid. However, let’s not forget that the Eurogroup statement from last week did not quantify any amount the deposit levy should yield but was kept rather general, saying that “the Eurogroup further welcomes the Cypriot authorities' commitment to take further measures mobilising internal resources, in order to limit the size of the financial assistance linked to the adjustment programme. These measures include the introduction of an upfront one-off stability levy applicable to resident and non-resident depositors. Further measures concern the increase of the withholding tax on capital income, a restructuring and recapitalisation of banks, an increase of the statutory corporate income tax rate and a bail-in of junior bondholders.” In European language this could eventually offer some room for manoeuvre.

Finding other financial sources seems to be the last straw in the eyes of the Cypriot government. There were several reports that Cyprus was trying to get financial support from Russia. Other options could be the increase of other taxes or privatisations. A combination of several options has recently been proposed by Russian energy giant Gazprom which according to media reports has offered Cyprus a plan in which the company will undertake the restructuring of the country’s banks in exchange for exploration rights for natural gas in Cyprus. Clearly an option with far-reaching geopolitical consequences.

However, even if Cyprus were to find other ways to finance its own contribution to the bailout package, it is doubtful whether the Eurogroup would go along with it. Last night, German finance minister Schäuble reiterated on German television that according to him the business model of the Cypriot economy had failed and needed a make-over.

Another option for Cyprus could be to come up with an own alternative for a private sector involvement, by for example exempting all insured depositors from the tax and replacing uninsured deposits above €100,000 with so-called bank certificates of deposit, linked to future natural gas revenues.

Earlier in the euro crisis, Greece called Angela Merkel’s bluff and the threat of being expelled from the Eurozone. It looks as if Greece’s neighbours now think that they can also call the Eurogroup’s bluff. They might be wrong. Even if the Eurozone eventually will probably offer some room for manoeuvre, it is hard to see that the German government will give up the demand for private sector involvement and far-reaching reforms of the Cypriot economy.

Monday, February 18, 2013

Fiscal storm ahead?

The European Commission’s latest economic forecasts will be presented on Friday. They should be the prelude to the first test case of the Eurozone’s ever-stricter fiscal rules.

Normally, releases of the European Commission’s economic forecasts pass by almost unnoticed and often lack financial markets’ interest. This time around, it should be different. When the European Commission presents its economic forecasts on Friday, market participants are well advised to have a closer look and pay particular attention to the fiscal forecasts. For the first time, the Commission will present a fully-fledged forecast in February. The forecasts for government budgets will form the basis for the next steps in the Eurozone’s fiscal surveillance.

Of course, fiscal surveillance in the Eurozone has become a rather complex mixture of prevention, correction, early warnings and ultimately even financial sanctions. The most straightforward surveillance is still the so-called Excessive Deficit Procedure (EDP). Enshrined in the Treaty, the EDP is the sanctionary or dissuasive arm of the Eurozone’s fiscal surveillance framework, stipulating a trajectory to correct excessive fiscal deficits and bring fiscal balances back in line with the threshold of 3% of GDP.





Currently, 12 out of 17 Eurozone countries are in an EDP. While the four bailed out countries (GR, SP, IR and PT) still have some time to bring their fiscal deficits back to 3% of GDP, the other eight countries had received 2012 or 2013 as a deadline to, as it is called, “correct the excessive deficit” (see Figure 1). For the countries with the 2012 deadline (IT, CY and BE), it will be thumbs up or thumbs down already before the summer. Normally, the Ecofin should decide on next steps in May. The European Council in June could take final decisions. For the countries with the 2013 deadline (FR, NL, AT, SL and SK), the Commission forecasts should send a clear signal of whether the countries are on the right track for fiscal consolidation or whether more austerity measures have to be taken.

The European Commission’s forecasts of last November suggest that the coming months could be the first big test case for the (once again) overhauled fiscal rules of the Eurozone. Back in November, only Belgium, Italy, Austria and the Netherlands were on track to meet their respective deadlines. Given the worse-than-expected growth environment in 2012 but also prospects for 2013, new fiscal slippages could be expected.

So what if a country fails or looks set to meet the required deadline? Eventually, not sticking to the official deadline could lead to a financial fine. Before this happens, however, the country in question will be given a last chance to take additional austerity measures. Or, following good European traditions, the deadline could be extended.

The option of an extended deadline is seen in the official fiscal rules. To qualify for an extended deadline, two criteria have to be fulfilled: 1) the country has to have implemented the required structural adjustment; and 2) fiscal slippages must have been caused by “unexpected adverse economic events”. An exact definition of these “unexpected adverse economic events” does not exist. In recent years, the severe 2009 recession led to an extension of EDP deadlines.

Given the above, at least three Eurozone countries will anxiously study the new European Commission forecasts on Friday. Cyprus and Slovenia seem to be off track in terms of both meeting the required deadline and fulfilling the structural adjustment. Clear evidence that Cyprus probably needs a fully-fledged bailout, rather than a bailout light only for its financial sector. France is a borderline case and could become the big challenge for the Eurozone’s fiscal framework. Last week, a French government official announced that the deficit target for this year will not be reached. This means that the deadline to bring the deficit back to 3% will be missed and, at the same time, the structural fiscal adjustment so far has anything but outperformed the requirements. Here, the deadline could be extended although sluggish growth, mainly due to home-made structural weaknesses, would obviously not be the most elegant way to define “unexpected adverse economic events”. The same holds for the fact that the economy falls clearly short of returning to the government’s assumed trend growth of 2.5% from 2011 onwards.

For the European Commission and eventually all Eurozone governments the question will be “sink or swim”. Strict application of the rules to regain credibility or softer (and for some smarter) application not to overburden the battered economies with additional austerity? Obviously, there are pros and cons for both options. An interesting side track will be the discussion on the methodology of structural adjustment. The structural adjustment is measured as the change of the cyclically-adjusted fiscal balance; a methodology that recently received some criticism in the context of the fiscal multiplier discussion.

The way forward will be a walk on a tightrope. The decisions of the coming months will not only have an impact on near-term economic prospects but will also more fundamentally pave the way for fiscal surveillance in the Eurozone.

Thursday, February 14, 2013

German GDP drops 0.6% QoQ in 4Q 12

Contraction confirmed. As expected, the German statistical agency just confirmed the biggest contraction of the German economy since Q1 2009. The economy contracted by 0.6% QoQ in the last quarter of 2012, slightly more than expected. Detailed components will only be released next week but according to the press statement of the statistical agency, construction, investment and, above all, exports dropped in the fourth quarter, while private and public consumption increased.


With increased uncertainty stemming from the euro crisis and the global economic cooling in the second half of the year, the German economy has finally lost its invincibility. Looking ahead, however, there is increasing evidence that the economy should pick up speed again very quickly. Confidence indicators have improved over the last three months and this new optimism is not only wishful thinking. The increase of new orders is again feeding the economy’s industrial growth engine. Moreover, the industrial safety net of filling order books and inventory reductions has improved, boding well for industrial production in the months ahead. Finally, if the lower-risk environment continues, record-low interest rates should support an investment rebound, contributing to growth in 2013.

All in all, even if today’s numbers are disappointing, they are no reason to start singing the blues on the German economy. The contraction should be a temporary gaffe rather than a new worrying reality.

Tuesday, January 29, 2013

Did anyone say shrinking?

One of the latest "hot stories" is the so-called currency war. The theory goes that central banks try to weaken their currencies by excessive liquidity. This week's earlier repayments of the first 3yr LTRO has given rise to fears that a shrinking ECB balance sheet would contribute to a stronger euro. However, there is some solace for the supporters of the shrinking theory: the ECB's balance sheet is still much higher than eg the Fed's. It would require the repayment of almost the entire take-up of the two 3 yr LTROs to immediately bring the ECB's balance sheet to US levels.

Friday, January 25, 2013

Ifo points to quick end of German contraction

The crisis is over. At least in Germany and at least if one believes in the forecasting power of the Ifo. Germany’s most prominent leading indicator, the Ifo index, increased in January for the third month in a row and stands now at 104.2; its highest level since June last year. Both, the current assessment and the expectation component improved. Particularly the improvement of expectations is remarkable. The combined improvement in December and January was the strongest 2-months improvement since the summer of 2009.


The contraction in the fourth quarter of 2012 seems to be short-lived. With biggest fears of a Eurozone break-up fading away and the improved outlook for the US and China, prospects for the German economy are also clearing off. Inventory build-up seems to have come to an end and order books have started to thicken again. In fact, it looks as if the gradual decoupling from the rest of the Eurozone is continuing. While business confidence has dropped in other core Eurozone countries like France and Belgium, German businesses are surfing on the wave of optimism. Is this the start of a core meltdown? German optimism could turn into reality as the main drivers behind the decoupling, or unique selling points of the economy, remain in place in 2013: export diversification, labour market strength and favourable financing conditions.

With last weekend’s elections in Lower Saxony, domestic politics have finally reached the forefront of Germany’s main themes of 2013. Normally, growth and elections go hand in hand. However, it looks as if strong growth of the past years and the expected recovery are rather taken as a given than an achievement of Merkel’s coalition. Stupid or not, it looks as if the economy will not be an active campaign worker for chancellor Merkel. If the recovery unfolds, it is taken for granted. If the recovery does not unfold and unemployment starts to increase, the opposition looks likely to benefit. It currently looks difficult for chancellor Merkel’s coalition to win the September elections purely on the country’s economic performance.

All in all, today’s Ifo index nicely illustrates the green shoots in the German economy. Even if the current harsh winter weather might delay the blossoming out somewhat, growth should return, leaving the contraction of the fourth quarter quickly behind.

Tuesday, January 22, 2013

Eurozone - Obviously enjoying the silence


At the first Eurogroup meeting of the year, Eurozone finance ministers gave the green light for the next tranche of the Greek loan and appointed a new Eurogroup president but postponed all other crucial and controversial issues.

Last night’s first Eurogroup meeting of the year reflected the general mood of important policymakers in the Eurozone: relax and take it easy, the worst of the crisis is over. Contrary to many meetings before, last night’s meeting was not heavily-loaded with crucial decisions. In fact, there were only two concrete decisions: i) Eurozone finance ministers took was to give the green light for the next tranche of the Greek loan, amounting to 9.2bn euro. 7.2bn euro will be for further bank recapitalisations and 2bn euro to finance the budget. And ii) Dutch finance minister Jeroen Dijsselbloem was officially appointed as successor of Jean-Claude Juncker as Eurogroup president. On all other issues, conclusions were postponed.


As regards Cyprus, the adjourned game continues. In fact, the Cypriot government already (unofficially though) asked for help last summer. Many Eurozone countries, above all the German, however, are hesitant to offer financial aid to a country they suspect to be a money laundering paradise. The German government was already reported as wanting to see Russia chipping in to the bailout, extending financial aid provided in 2011 when Russia provided a €2.5bn euro loan to Cypriotic banks.


No official figures have been put forward yet but wire reportes refer to a bailout package of around 17bn euro (which would be around 100% of GDP). A €17bn bailout would mean that Cyprus' debt - currently over 70% of GDP - would reach 170%, way more than the troika of international lenders has ever accepted as "sustainable" for other bailout states. One crucial question is therefore whether Cyprus, or better holders of Cypriotic government bonds, should receive a haircut. A Greek-style haircut could create new turmoil on bond markets as it would “aufheben” the earlier promise that the Greek haircuts were one-offs (even if the ESM Treaty includes the option of exceptional private sector involvement). Moreover, as most bondholders are probably the banks themselves, a Greek-style haircut could increase the recapitalisaiton needs. However, a bailout out without any private sector involvement should be hard to sell politically in some Eurozone core countries. As a consequence, privatisations and eventually some baill-in of bank debt owners could become part of any bailout agreement.


The other controversial issue of the coming weeks and months remains the direct bank recapitalisation by the ESM once the single supervisory mechanisme is up and running. Unsolved issues are obviously how much money the ESM could spend on bank recapitalisation without jeopardising the financial capacity to bailout more governments, whether ESM should be the first or rather the final line of defence, whether the ESM should be allowed to fund “legacy assets” (mistakes from the past) and whether direct bank recapitalisation could be applied retroactively (for Spain and Ireland).


Eurozone policymakers are obviously enjoying the calm on financial markets. The copious time spent on and the obsession with the right pronunciation of the name of the new Eurogroup president, Dutch finance minister Jeroen Dijsselbloem,suggests that imminent pressure to deliver concrete results has faded away. Let’s hope it does not lead to complacency.

Friday, December 14, 2012

EU Summit - all is calm but not all is bright

The last EU summit of the year turned out to be a tranquil pre-Christmas meeting. After finance ministers’ decisions on Greece and bank supervision, EU leaders slowed down their reform efforts. The famous roadmap towards further integration of the Eurozone has been delayed once again. In the tranquil pre-Christmas mood, some EU leaders might have started singing Christmas carols last night. However, unlike in the Christmas song “Silent night, holy night”, all is calm but not all is bright.


What initially was meant to be the big break-through for the Eurozone and course-setter towards a “genuine economic and monetary union”, turned out to be a tranquil year-end summit. Already ahead of government leaders’ arrival to Brussels last night, finance ministers had cleared the way towards a sunshine and roses evening. The EU and the Eurozone have ended the year with the typical mixture of delivering the bare minimum without overachieving a single tiny bit.

The first bare minimum was the break-through on Eurozone bank supervision. After another long meeting, European finance ministers agreed on a single supervisory mechanism for the Eurozone. Non-Eurozone countries can join on a voluntary basis. Supervision of the biggest banks (with balance sheets above 30bn euro or above 20% of a country’s GDP) will be conducted by the ECB, in cooperation with national supervisors. This new Single Supervisory Mechanism (SSM) will become effective in March 2014 at the earliest. Further delays cannot be excluded.

The SSM is meant to be the first step towards a fully-fledged banking union which should break the vicious link between sovereigns and financials. Remember that officially the ESM will be allowed to directly recapitalize banks once the SSM has become effective. Obviously, this will now have to wait at least until March 2014. A time line which clearly pleases the German and other core countries’ governments which still are opposing direct bank recapitalisation for legacy assets, or in other words: core Eurozone countries are not yet willing to put taxpayers’ money on the table to pay the bill of peripheral countries’ financial mistakes of the past. Further steps to complete a real banking union, in theory, would have to be a bank resolution mechanism and a deposit guarantee scheme. Up to now, Eurozone countries are still far off from any agreement on these two issues. Next year, the European Commission will present a first proposal for a bank resolution mechanism. All of this means that after the usual post-marathon meeting euphoria, the decision on the SSM is clearly not a game changer for the Eurozone.

The second bare minimum finance ministers delivered was the final green light to pay the next loan tranche for Greece, amounting to 49.1bn euro. The disbursement will be made in several tranches. The first 34.3bn euro will be paid out in the next days. The rest in the course of the first quarter, partly conditional to further Troika assessments. As we have often said in the past, yesterday’s green light for Greece clears another hurdle but it was not the last hurdle.

Agreement on Greece and the SSM, however, masks that there still is lots of disagreement on other crucial topics, not only on direct bank recapitalisation. Let’s not forget that this week’s summit was intended to even go further and to deliver a roadmap towards more or “genuine” integration. However, last night, EU leaders did not agree on anything else. EU president Van Rompuy’s roadmap had been downgraded to a background document. Binding contracts between countries and institutions to ensure structural reforms, financial incentives for structural reforms, a mechanism to absorb asymmetric shocks, harmonization of tax policies and labour markets? All these issues have been postponed until at least the summer of 2013. More visionary ideas which could have strengthened prevention by reducing national sovereignty like a Eurozone finance minister have disappeared entirely.

The crisis year 2012 comes to a close. It is a tranquil, almost conciliatory, year-end.Yesterday’s agreements on Greece and the SSM are already an achievement. Particularly the SSM is something no one had on the radar screen at the beginning of the year. Within the last year, next to the never-ending fire fighting in Greece, the Eurozone has managed to agree on a fiscal compact with mandatory national debt breaks, start the ESM and set up a Eurozone-wide banking supervision. Even if this week’s summit clearly disappointed on the vision thing, showing that there still is lots of disagreement, let’s try to be mild and not too critical: the Eurozone is still alive and it is moving into the right direction, even if it sometimes moves at a very slow speed. Enjoy the summit-free time, it won’t last for long.






Friday, December 7, 2012

German IP crashes in October

Heading towards contraction. German industrial production dropped by a sharp 2.6% MoM in October, from -1.3% in September, providing further evidence that the economy’s backbone is quickly losing steam. In annual growth terms, industrial production is down by 3.7%. The drop was driven by all sectors except for non-durable consumer goods. Production in the construction sector fell sharply by 5.3% MoM.

The German decoupling from the rest of the Eurozone has come to an end. Strong trading ties with non-Eurozone countries had shielded the economy against the euro crisis. Now, with the global economic cooling in the second half of the year, this immunity is quickly fading away. The thinning out of order books throughout the year is finally feeding through to the real economy.

There are currently two opposing trends in the German economy. In the short term, the “deflating” of order books on the back of the euro crisis and a weaker global economy should continue to feed through to activity. With today’s industrial production data, a contraction of the economy in the fourth quarter has almost become inevitable. Even a technical recession of two consecutive quarters cannot be excluded entirely, particularly if the fiscal cliff negotiations in the US disappoint and hamper the US recovery. Looking beyond the next one or two quarters, however, the German economy should be able to pick up speed relatively quickly. The latest improvement in confidence indicators and new orders clearly indicate that the current industrial slump should be rather short-lived.

Our general take on the German economy remains positive. However, today’s industrial data shows that unfortunately things first have to get worse before they get better.
 

Wednesday, November 21, 2012

Eurozone - Haste makes waste

Eurozone finance ministers have a strong affinity for cliff-hangers. Last night’s almost twelve-hour meeting did not bring any conclusion on how to finance more time for Greece. The decision was postponed until next week Monday.


The only thing that is clear after last night’s Eurozone finance minister meeting is that nothing is clear. The Eurogroup postponed the decision on how to finance more time for the Greek adjustment to next week Monday. The phrase in the official statement that “the Eurogroup has had an extensive discussion and made progress in identifying a consistent package of credible initiatives aimed at making a further substantial contribution to the sustainability of Greek government debt” shows that disagreement remains deep.

For once, Greece had apparently no responsibility for the further delay. Indeed, the final statement praises Greece for having met all prior actions required ahead of the meeting, citing structural reforms, the budget for 2013 and the 2013-2016 medium term fiscal strategy. Data released yesterday by the Greek Ministry of Finance confirmed that progresses in the implementation of the adjustment are indeed being made, with the state sector budget execution ahead of schedule at end of October.

At the Eurogroup level, the two issues at stake still are: i) the financing of the Greek funding gap, resulting from two additional years to adjust, and ii) how to restore long-term debt sustainability. Finding the money for two additional years (up to 32bn euro) is probably the easier task than restoring debt sustainability. According to latest reports, Greek debt will rather be above 140% of GDP in 2020 than close to the official target of 120%. In euro, this gap in 2010 will probably amount to 70bn to 100bn. Finding such an amount requires lots of financial creativity as long as Eurozone countries do not want to embark on clean-cut solutions like debt forgiveness or a third package. The current deadlock seems to result from strongly diverging views between the IMF and the Eurozone on how to restore debt sustainability. While the IMF favours a clear-cut solution, most Eurozone countries seem to support a the fudge option, interpreting debt sustainability in a more flexible manner than the IMF.

Last night’s meeting has again shown that that the Greek case pushes the limits of Eurozone finance ministers’ financial creativity. Or to put it more positively: maybe ministers just follow the principle of haste makes waste.



Tuesday, October 30, 2012

Greek days have started


With three meetings in less than two weeks, Eurozone finance minsters hope to finally strike a deal on giving Greece more time for its adjustment.

The decisive phase for Greece has started. Yesterday, Eurogroup president Juncker announced an unscheduled meeting of Eurozone finance ministers on 8 November. With the scheduled conference call of ministers on 31 October and the already planned Eurogroup meeting on 12 November, ministers will have three meetings to decide on further steps for Greece. Even if the Troika report has not (yet) been officially released, it seems clear that the Eurozone is willing to give Greece somewhat more time for the adjustment.

More time, however, would eventually also cost more money. According to earlier market reports, a two years delay of the austerity measures could lead to a financing gap of between 15bn and 30bn euro. This financing gap would have to be closed to keep the IMF on board of the Greek rescue and to be able to pay out the next tranche of the loan. Of course, always assuming that Greece fulfills its obligations of the structural reforms and austerity measures.

Generally speaking, more time for Greece could be “bought” by two main options: a third bailout package or debt forgiveness. This is what according to media report is also proposed by the Troika. However, none of these two options is politically attractive for most Eurozone countries as both options would cost tax payers’ money. Therefore, it did not come as a surprise that the German government directly and indirectly tried to rule out both options, with opposition against debt forgiveness being much louder than against a third package. Particularly, German chancellor Merkel seems to be – very gradually – giving up opposition against a third aid package. While a third Greek bailout would probably not be supported by all of her own coalition’s lawmakers, Merkel could get parliamentary support from the biggest opposition party, the social democrats. Less than one year ahead of the federal elections, Eurozone matters could increasingly be dominated by German domestic politics.

Debt forgiveness (aka Official Sector Involvement) would, according to the German government, be against the principle of no-bailout principle (for the government) and against the principle of no-monetary financing (for the ECB). While the monetary financing argument remains a strong one for the ECB, the no-bailout argument looks much weaker, particularly in light of all rescue actions of the last years. As a consequence, some kind of OSI should not entirely be ruled out. However, it would not come for free for Greece. In our view, OSI or debt forgiveness would come with even more strings attached than the current programmes, leading to more and far-reaching loss of sovereignty. The core Eurozone countries would do everything to avoid the impression that OSI is relief for free. Otherwise, other Eurozone peripheral countries could be tempted to ask for the same.

Given the broader consequences of an OSI or debt forgiveness and the limited political appetite in several Eurozone parliaments for a third bailout package, filling the funding gap for Greece will again require some creativity. A possible way out, at least in the short-term, could be a combination of several options like lowering the interest rates on the first two Greek packages and front-loading parts of the funding of the second package. This could again kick the Greek can further down the road.


Friday, October 19, 2012

EU Summit - Long night, few results

The first session of this week’s European Summit was again one of these red-eyed long nights with few concrete results. The new bank supervisory mechanism will come but will not be effective on 1 January 2013.


During a 10-hour marathon, European leaders discussed nothing less than the future of the monetary union or – to be more precise – EU president Van Rompuy’s report on possible paths to more Eurozone integration.

It was already obvious from the start that probably the only really fruitful discussion would be on the banking union. The principle agreement on common bank supervision had already been taken in June but negotiations on the exact implementation had slowed significantly recently with rising tensions between Eurozone countries on details and the possible starting date.

In a typical European compromise, which had something for everyone, European leaders last night called for “swift progress, with the objective of agreeing on the legislative framework by 1st of January 2013. Once this is agreed, the Single Supervisory Mechanism could probably be effectively operational in the course of 2013.” This compromise had the “1st of January 2013” that French president Hollande wanted and the “course of 2013” for German chancellor Merkel. Even if the countries can agree on a common legal framework before the end of the year, it would not become effective on 1st of January due to national implementation and ratification processes.

Details of the new bank supervision will still be worked out by finance ministers in the coming months. It seems clear that the ECB will play “a central part” and that all banks will fall under supervision. However, the phrase “the ECB should also be able to carry out supervision directly in a differentiated manner, meaning: using national supervisors in regular supervisory tasks as much as possible” shows that Germany succeeded in getting different treatments for some of its smaller banks and particularly the saving banks (Sparkassen).

The issue of direct bank recapitalization by the ESM once an effective supervisor has been established was also confirmed last night. However, operational criteria will still have to be developed which in our view implies that the issue of legacy assets will remain on the table. It looks unlikely that Germany, Finland and the Netherlands will give this one up during the upcoming negotiations.

The “vision-thing” on deeper integration of the monetary union will continue. Reading between the lines of Van Rompuy’s official statement, there does not seem to be a lot of agreement on anything. Strong emphasis on the measures already taken up to now is always a bad sign. It also shows that Germany’s latest idea of a super-Commissioner seems to be off the table. The only element explicitly mentioned last night by Van Rompuy was the issue of individual reform contracts. Other issues like a possible Eurozone budget or emergency fund are mentioned in code language and could still return in the next report to be presented at the EU summit in December.

All in all, the new single supervisory mechanism will come but direct bank recapitalization looks very unlikely any time soon. Moreover, all other big-picture issues for deeper Eurozone integration remain schematic. The integration pace remains slow. Last night’s marathon session again illustrated how cumbersome and difficult the European decision-making process is.

Friday, October 12, 2012

European Day of Imaginativeness

A week ahead of the next EU Summit, new ideas, proposals and suggestions come thick and fast. However, the traditional jumble of ideas looks unlikely to already lead to concrete conclusions next week.


It was an eventful day yesterday. Several senior officials presented ideas, proposals and suggestions on possible next steps in the euro crisis. IMF head Christine Lagarde was the first, saying that the IMF was striving to save Greece, but that the country may need two years more than planned to get back on its own feet. Of course, Lagarde stated only the obvious, namely that the recessions in Eurozone peripheral countries currently undermined the austerity efforts, leading to a downward spiral – and not only in Greece. However, just one week ahead of the next EU summit and still awaiting the Troika report on Greece, Lagarde’s comments come at a sensitive moment.

Over the last weeks, there had already been signals that the Eurozone (including Germany) could be willing to give Greece more time. More time, however, would eventually also cost more money. According to market reports, a two-year delay of the austerity measures could lead to a financing gap of between €15bn and €30bn. Generally speaking, more time for Greece could be “bought” by two main options: a third bailout package or debt forgiveness. Within these boundaries, options like lower interest rates on the Greek loans, front-loading of the current bailout package and fiddling around with medium-term growth forecasts or a combination of all options could still be on the agenda.

Interestingly, German Finance Minister Schaeuble reacted immediately after Lagarde’s comments at the IMF/World Bank meetings, saying that debt forgiveness was not an issue. However, he did not comment on the possibility of giving Greece more time with its adjustment programme.

While Christine Lagarde increased pressure on Eurozone policymakers, not only to solve the Greek issue but also to seriously tackle the issue of Eurozone integration, EU President Van Rompuy revealed more details of his building blocks for more integration. At a speech in Brussels, Van Rompuy reiterated the three main areas of further integration: financial affairs, budgetary matters and economic policies. According to Van Rompuy, the immediate priority was progress in the banking sector with the well known Single Supervisory Mechanism. However, even if Van Rompuy called the efforts for a Single Supervisory Mechanism a sprint in the midst of an EMU marathon, this sprint looks more like a 800m run than a 100m sprint as principle agreement is still overshadowed by disagreement on many details.

The newest kid in the Eurozone integration town is the so-called fiscal capacity. This is a new buzzword which simply means a new Eurozone crisis fund to help suffering countries to fulfill all adjustment requirements. Eventually, this could become something like an unemployment compensation mechanism or a social solidarity mechanism. However, size, purpose, conditions and funding source are still more than unclear. Another new idea, which eventually could be linked to financial incentives, is to put structural reforms into binding contracts. Elsewhere yesterday, EP president Martin Schulz suggested that the next European elections could already see transnational front-runners.

All in all, the debate continues. Next week’s summit will probably not (yet) lead to any substantial conclusions; neither on Greece nor on further integration. Yesterday’s events nicely illustrated that Europe remains a region of thinkers and poets. There is clearly no lack of ideas, sometimes only of concrete decisions.

Tuesday, September 18, 2012

Enjoying the silence


It was the week of relief. The German Constitutional Court’s ruling on the ESM and the Dutch elections were a blow to eurosceptics, pushing EMU break-up speculations away and leading to positive reactions on financial markets. The meeting of Eurozone finance ministers in Cyprus and yesterday’s comments by German chancellor Merkel, however, showed that several important issues still remain unsolved.

In the short term, Spain and Greece should get the most attention. Many market participants expect Spain to be the next one in line to ask for a bailout, even if it is a bailout light, and consequently be the first country to fall under the ECB’s new OMT programme. So far, however, no decision has been taken and it increasingly looks as if nothing will happen before the ESM has become operational (expected date 8 October) and the regional elections in Spain (21 October). By then, the Troika should finally have presented its report on Greece. There seems to be a growing consensus among Eurozone policymakers to give Greece more time as long as it does not cost more money. Whether this is feasible or pure magic remains to be seen. Yesterday, German chancellor Merkel again put forth her hand to Greece, stressing that she wanted Greece to stay in the Eurozone and that Germany was ready to help. It is up to Greece to grab the hand.

Unsolved short-term issues are not the only unfinished business in the Eurozone. The biggest work in progress – steps towards further integration – also proves to be more cumbersome and difficult than some euro-optimists might have thought. The first building block towards further integration, a banking union, was presented last week, but so far all Eurozone member states only embrace the principle of Eurozone bank supervision but largely disagree on the details. Over the last couple of days, the German government has tried to slow down the pace of a fully-fledged Eurozone bank supervision. Given the strict German opposition, a joint Eurozone deposit insurance scheme has more or less been postponed until a very distant future. More generally speaking, the longer the negotiations on the entire building blocks for a “genuine economic and monetary union” will last, the more difficult it could be to get Germany on board. Why? It will be election time in Germany next year.

The latest events have bought more time for the Eurozone. However, neither the ECB’s announced OMT programme, nor the German Court’s ruling on the ESM nor the Dutch elections have improved the fundamental situation of Eurozone economies. Spanish unemployment remains high, Italy and France still suffer from a lack of competitiveness and Greek debt has not become any more sustainable. Moreover, the roadmap towards further Eurozone integration remains a bit vague and there are obviously still diverging views. In sum, still a lot of unfinished work. It would be a false conclusion to think that the Eurozone has suddenly become a hunky dory country in which they play Depeche Mode all day long.

Wednesday, September 12, 2012

German Court says "yes, but..." to ESM


More relief for the Eurozone. The German Constitutional Court ruled in favour of the ESM. The strings attached to the Court’s ‘yes’ seem softer than in past verdicts.
In its long-awaited ruling, the German Constitutional Court yesterday gave the green light for the ESM and the fiscal compact. The Court said “yes, but…”, adding some conditions to the German approval. As expected, all emphasis was on preventing unlimited financial liability for German tax payers and ensuring that the German parliament remains responsible for the budget. The “but’s” in the Court’s verdict are small but significant.
The Court ruled that German liabilities have to be capped at the current contribution of 190bn euro. This cap should be mandatory under international law. Any future increase of the ESM’s capacity would require approval by the German parliament. Moreover, the Court ruled that the clauses on immunity and professional secrecy for Board members of the ESM should not apply for the information flow to the German parliament. This is an indirect accountability clause. As a consequence, German president Gauck should now be able to sign the Treaty once the cap on the German contribution has been laid down in international law.
At least at first glance, the Court’s ruling surprises somewhat by the absence of stricter conditions. The Court did not ask for definite limits and did not identify violations of the democratic principle.
Within less than a week, the Eurozone has finally received its long sought-after impressive bazooka: conditional but unlimited ECB bond purchases and the ESM which provides a new fresh lending capacity of 500bn euro. Of course, it is a bazooka with potential risks and side-effects. As a result, Eurozone governments have now received more time to do their homework, implement reforms and austerity measures. Today’s ruling has not solved the crisis, neither has last week’s ECB decision. However, after monetary and legal authorities have done their part, the destiny of the Eurozone is now exclusively in the hands of governments.